The update seemed to go smoothly at first. After the initial reboot, the ClockWork Mod recovery that I ran prompted me for two things: "ROM may flash stock recovery on boot. Fix?" and, "Root access possibly lost. Fix?" Both times, I instructed it to try to fix the problem, but that probably didn't matter. When the update was finished, I found that I'd lost root access, which wasn't unexpected. There are apps that help you keep root access after an update, but they're known to not work with 4.3 thanks to Samsung's new KNOX security setup introduced with 4.3. I also found that I'd lost WiFi support in my phone, which I did not expect because I didn't do my research. As it turns out, broken WiFi is actually a common problem.
Among other things, KNOX creates a "warranty void" bit in the firmware that gets set as soon as you install a new ROM or custom recovery. Unlike the install counter that already existed, this flag can't be reset by any known means. Once you trigger it, your warranty is over. Anybody else starting to really hate Samsung right about now? I guess the takeaway from this is that you shouldn't do anything goofy with your phone until after you've owned it for a month or two and are confident that you don't have a lemon that may need warranty service.
I finally got around to doing the research I should have done earlier, and found that there are solutions to these problems, but they are labor intensive. Developers on the xda-developers.com forums (lorjay, specifically) hacked the 4.3 release when it first appeared and made available "custom ROMs" that were basically just the original factory ROM, minus KNOX, plus root access. They fixed the broken WiFi, too.
The most newbie-friendly explanation of the process that I could find came from this post on the xda-developers forum. Just in case it goes away, I'll reiterate it here, with my own comments.
- Download the Samsung drivers for Windows, Odin, the PhilZ Touch 6 custom recovery (most recent tar.md5), the WiFi patch, and most importantly, the MK4 4.3 ROM (dodexed, full root) for your phone.
- Get a good app/data/settings backup of your phone, and copy it to your computer. I use MyBackup Pro, but Titanium is also popular.
- Clear off 10GB or so of free space on your external sdcard. If you don't have an external micro-sd card in your Galaxy Note II, then you're pretty well screwed here. Go buy one. The more data you have stored on your phone (Google music, anybody?), the more free space you'll need.
- Install the Samsung drivers on your PC, plug your phone into the USB port on your computer, and mount the phone for browsing folders. Copy the MK4 ROM to the top level of your phone's external sdcard.
- Install the PhilZ custom recovery in the next two steps: Power off the phone. Boot it into download mode by simultaneously pressing power, home, and volume down. When you see the warning, press volume up.
- Plug the phone into the computer (if it's not already there). Launch Odin. You should see a COM port listed for your phone. Click the "PDA" button and select the PhilZ tar.md5 file. Click "Start." It will flash the phone, then reboot the phone. You may have to reboot the phone again, after which Odin will say, "PASS." You may now unplug the phone from the computer.
- Power off the phone, then boot it into the recovery app by simultaneously holding power, home, and volume up.
- In PhilZ, select "Backup and Restore," then "Custom," then "Custom Backup Job." Make sure the following are selected with an (X): boot, recovery, system, preload, and-sec, modem, /data, and /data/media. Although, if your phone was previously rooted and you have a full filesystem backup, you can probably skip /data/media to save some time. Now begin the backup by selecting "Start custom backup job," and save it to /storage/sdcard1 (your external micro-sd card). This step took me about 45 minutes.
- Repeat the previous step, but this time make sure that only EFS is selected to be backed up. Your main phone memory is now completely backed up. If you're nervous, boot the phone back up normally and copy the sdcard contents over to your computer, just in case.
- In PhilZ, select "Wipe data/factory reset" and then "Clean to install new ROM."
- Now select "Mounts and Storage" and then "Format /data and /data/media." Congratulations. You've completely erased the OS from your phone. Go change your underwear.
- From the top level PhilZ menu, select "Install zip," then "Choose zip from /storage/sdcard." Select the ROM that you want to install. This took me only a few minutes.
- After install, reboot the phone. Mine took a couple minutes to reboot, then prompted me to select the language for initial setup of a new phone. Don't go through that setup yet, though.
- Power off the phone, then boot into the download manager.
- Install the WiFi patch using Odin, just like you did for the PhilZ custom recovery.
- The phone will automatically reboot on its own. Once it comes back up, reboot it again yourself.
- You now have a fully functional, rooted, 4.3 ROM without KNOX. Of course, it's a fresh phone, so you'll have to setup the new phone and restore everything from backups. That's actually the longest step of the process. I'd block off at least an entire evening for this whole routine.
no other reason than it allows me to get good backups of my device.
Unfortunately, it seems that my phone reboots spontaneously from time to time with the new ROM. This happened when I was trying to restore my app backup, so many of the apps didn't get restored properly, and had to be restored piecemeal as I discovered them. I think I've finally got all those done now, but it took far longer than it should have.
I've also seen that my phone occasionally reports that my WiFi connection is unstable. It doesn't do it very often, and I haven't noticed any ill effects like terminated connections. I may have to look into that one further. I though that the WiFi patch mentioned above was supposed to correct that problem.
If you include all the research that I did along with the time it took to reconfigure all my apps that didn't get restored initially, this whole process took me about four evenings. To add insult to injury, I haven't noticed any improvements resulting from the 4.3 upgrade. I certainly wouldn't recommend doing this upgrade unless you're really bored or curious. I will definitely not be installing it on my wife's rooted Galaxy S3.
Have you installed the 4.3 update on your Samsung phone? How did that work out for you? Please share your experience in the comments below.